The Failure Of Peer Review — Especially In Medicine

lkfitz's bookmarks 2018-02-05

Summary:

"Going back at least as far as 1996 journalists and researchers have been getting spoof papers published in conferences or journals to deliberately expose weaknesses in academic quality controls. “Physicist Alan Sokal (of the famous Sokal Affair) succeeded in the journal Social Text in 1996,” while Harvard science journalist John Bohannon revealed in a 2013 issue of Science that he had duped over 150 open-access journals into publishing “a deliberately flawed study.”[19] Bohannon organized submission of the flawed study (technically, many different but very similar variations of the study) to 304 open access journals worldwide over a period of 10 months. 255 went through the whole editing process to the point of either acceptance or rejection."

Link:

https://www.solvibrations.org/failure-of-peer-review%e2%80%8a/

From feeds:

Open Access Tracking Project (OATP) » lkfitz's bookmarks

Tags:

oa.new oa.peer_review oa.medicine oa.predatory oa.quality oa.credibility

Date tagged:

02/05/2018, 09:40

Date published:

02/05/2018, 04:40