Open sourcing Lucy, the world’s most famous fossil | Ars Technica

lterrat's bookmarks 2017-01-02

Summary:

"Forty years after she was discovered, Lucy, the world’s most famous fossil australopithecine, just might have a cause of death. In August of this year, a team of paleoanthropologists led by John Kappelman argued in Nature that Lucy died 3.2 million years ago by falling out of a tree. Their conclusion has been met with skepticism among fellow researchers, and Lucy's death-by-tree-fall hypothesis has generated no shortage of debate within the scientific community of paleoanthropology.

But there's a takeaway here that's more significant than the study’s conclusion—this study's approach to sharing data with the scientific community and the public at large. In a move that is in keeping with the growing trend across paleoanthropology and other sciences to open up access to data, the study’s scientists have published CT scans of Lucy’s tibia, femur, humerus, and scapula—all bones they analyzed in their study. Now, they invite colleagues, detractors, educators, and ardent fossil enthusiasts to download and print Lucy’s scans, encouraging audiences to 'evaluate the hypothesis for themselves.'

 

Why was publishing Lucy’s scans so significant? This paleoanthropology initiative does in some way tie into to the broader movement for open access, transparency, and reproducibility in science. But does publishing fossil data actually  help create knowledge within the paleoanthropological community?

Historically, discoveries of hominins (fossil human ancestors) are relatively few and far between. Since every scrap of fossil has a role to play in parsing out the human evolutionary tree, paleoanthropology’s methodology depends heavily on access to those fossils in order to go about the everyday business of doing its science. Scientists depend on access to original fossils, access to casts of fossils, and access to the data taken from those fossils. And as a science that is heavily dependent on the significance of new discoveries, access is a crucial aspect of paleoanthropology’s study of human evolution. Without it, scientists are unable to test hypotheses, replicate studies, or verify conclusions—let alone ask any new questions."

Link:

http://arstechnica.com/science/2017/01/open-sourcing-lucy-the-worlds-most-famous-fossil/

From feeds:

Open Access Tracking Project (OATP) » lterrat's bookmarks

Tags:

oa.biology

Date tagged:

01/02/2017, 16:09

Date published:

01/02/2017, 11:09