Unilever Centre for Molecular Informatics, Cambridge - Repository Fringe 11: McBlawg, and a Question for everyone « petermr's blog

abernard102@gmail.com 2013-07-11


I’ve spent much of last week at the Repository Fringe in Edinburgh (see http://www.repositoryfringe.org/ which has a really excellent “live blog” – almost verbatim; also see #rfringe11 for tweets). It was an interesting event with the normal complete spectrum from geeks hacking repo software and content, to those who are making policy, financing repositories and getting (or not getting) engagement ... Graham (McDawg and McBlawg) is a prominent and tireless campaigner for Open Access and Open Knowledge. He devotes his own time and money to the cause ... I have highlighted the 'Patient Advocate' as that is what, in large part, has driven Graham to demand Open Knowledge. Graham was a co-founder of the CJD Alliance (http://www.cjdalliance.net/ ) and describes himself in 'Patients Like Me' (http://www.patientslikeme.com/members/view/1644) : 'Graham has several years experience of obtaining and sharing information between researchers and patients – and now Journals. The patient as always, remains at the forefront – always will.  Graham Steel (42) is a native of Glasgow, Scotland, and works as a property claims adjuster/recovery specialist.  Graham’s brother, Richard, was diagnosed with variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease (vCJD) in April 1999 and died in November 1999 at the age of 33.  Graham joined the committee of the Human BSE Foundation on a voluntary basis in September 2001 and became a Trustee as of 2003 after the Foundation became a Charity.  Since September 2001, he acted as Vice-Chair.  One of his main initial and continued foci had been to develop and maintain the Foundation’s website. Graham left this organisation in October 2005.  Over the last few years, Graham has devoted much time learning more of the background of TSE’s and so called Prion disease, the current and emerging rationale of treatment issues/early diagnostic methodologies and maintaining/seeking contact with many researchers in several  Continents. He has also devoted much time assisting in forging links between a number of CJD related support groups from around the world.'  So does anyone, anywhere, defend the current system that denies Graham access to the world’s published medical literature?  ... So, UK repositories, I am going to start asking you questions. They are simple to phrase and should be simple to answer. I proposed one as a “good idea” at the RepoFringe. It didn’t win a prize, but it did get helpful comments ... It was phrased in LinkedOpenData language (including the RDF dragon) so I will state it more simply here:  PLEASE GIVE ME A LIST OF ALL THE CONTENT IN ALL UK REPOSTIORIES ... I think that’s a simple and responsible question. (Please do not tell me I can write software to recursively iterate over the UK repos using OAI-PMH). I want a list. For Graham and others. So they can look at it and see what is and what is not in the UK academic store of knowledge.  Here’s my simple arithmetic. ca 200 UK repositories. Most have << 10,000 entries (I asked at the meeting). Soton (one of the most active and also driven from the top) has ca 25,000 (as replied at the meeting) Several have < 1000 entries (from the meeting) Assuming ca 2000 entries for 200 repos (power law) we get ca 400,000 items. [Jim Downing and I have personally put ca 200,000 data items into Cambridge repository. I'm discounting these] ...  Many repos have been running for 10 years. I’ll take an average of 3 year for the 200. That gives 600 repo-years in UK ... Let’s assume that’s 1000 person-years full-economic-costs at 100 K GBP / year = 100 million GBP

Now, before you complain that you don’t get paid anything like 100K GBP, that is about the average amount request for a postdoc from a research council. It takes into account the computing infrastructure, mowing the lawns, holding meetings, etc. And on top of that there are those supported to develop software and develop projects. An auditor could reasonably claim that our group had >>200K GBP of JISC grant over the years just for repositories and that’s independent of the actual university costs and support."

So my current arithmetic is:

100,000,000 GBP for 400,000 items

That’s 250 GBP per item deposited.

QUESTION 1: I need to know exactly on (let’s say) August 31 2011 how many entries there are in UK institutional repositories

Assuming I get some answers then I will move onto the next questions. Which are all, ultimately, leading up to knowing how much Open Knowledge do we have and what use is it.



From feeds:

Open Access Tracking Project (OATP) » abernard102@gmail.com


oa.new oa.comment oa.green oa.advocacy oa.libraries oa.events oa.ir oa.uk oa.librarians oa.pharma oa.biomedicine oa.patientslikeme oa.repositories

Date tagged:

07/11/2013, 06:56

Date published:

07/11/2013, 02:56