University Requires Students To Pay $180 For 'Art History' Text That Has No Photos Due To Copyright Problems | Techdirt 2012-09-19


Brent Ashley shares the absolutely crazy story of how his daughter, a student at OCAD University in Canada, is taking a class on ‘Global Visual and Material Culture: Prehistory to 1800’ which has a textbook that is required for all students... which costs $180. Now, we all know that textbook prices are absolutely insane these days, but here's where it gets crazier. The text -- and, remember, this is an art textbook has no images because they couldn't clear the copyrights: ‘This year, however, the textbook for Global VISUAL and Material Culture has no pictures. Students have been told that the publisher couldn’t get the copyright permissions settled in time for the print run, so students will have to read the book, and see the pictures online by following along on their computer.  There is no discount on the $180 price for an ART textbook that has NO PICTURES. Devoid of pictures. Bereft of art. If I am going to have to pay $180 for an art history book that is of no resale value to next year’s students, it had damn well better be an excellent visual reference with hard cover and full colour plates, to keep around for years, festooning my coffee table and that of my heirs.’  Students in the class have put up a petition to protest what they quite correctly call a ‘sham.’ It's even more bizarre given that recent court rulings in Canada would suggest that the images in question would be given pretty broad ‘fair dealing’ protections for the purpose of education. But, just the threat of copyright claims, apparently, are creating an absolutely ridiculous situation.”


From feeds:

Open Access Tracking Project (OATP) »

Tags: oa.business_models oa.publishers oa.licensing oa.comment oa.advocacy oa.signatures oa.petitions oa.copyright oa.students oa.textbooks oa.prices oa.fair_use oa.canada oa.images oa.art_history oa.ocad.u oa.books oa.libre

Date tagged:

09/19/2012, 16:11

Date published:

09/19/2012, 12:11