Judge Leval Illuminates Google Books Fair Use Issues Second Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment for Defendant in Massive Copying Case | Fenwick & West LLP - JDSupra

"Based on the defense of fair use, the Second Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Google in the decade-long copyright battle between an authors group and the Internet search giant. The lawsuit concerned Google’s right to copy millions of books in order to allow snippet searches and text/data mining of the works. Making digital copies 'to provide a search function is a transformative use,' the panel held, 'which augments public knowledge by making available information about Plaintiffs’ books without providing the public with a substantial substitute for matter protected by the Plaintiffs’ copyright….' Authors Guild v. Google, Inc., 804 F.3d 202 (2d Cir. 2015). To many legal observers, the outcome seemed obvious in light of the limited uses to which Google sought to affix the imprimatur of fair use. But the opinion, authored by Judge Pierre Leval, takes a number of original turns in reaching this conclusion. Twenty-five years ago, Judge Leval wrote the seminal copyright article on which rested the Supreme Court’s “transformative fair use” analysis in Campbell v. Acuff-Rose, 510 U.S. 569 (1994). The Google Books case gave Judge Leval an opportunity to return to the issue and elucidate transformativeness in a technology context ..."