Public Open Statements/public statement against author-facing · master · Publishing Reform / discussion · GitLab

peter.suber's bookmarks 2019-01-20


"1. We hereby state our strong opposition to any implementation of scholarly publishing based on submission and publication fees charged to authors. This includes page charges for traditional subscription journals, and open access journals charging an author fee per article (APC). There must be no financial barriers to submission or publication placed in the way of authors of research articles. 

2. Our opposition to author fees is based on: 

i) the historically observed fact that the global system of research and scholarship works best when barriers to participation by authors and readers are as low as possible; ii) the principle of fairness to authors - joining the global conversation should not be limited by inability to pay, or lack of powerful sponsors who will pay, but should depend on the quality of the author's research; iii) the fact that author fee waivers that take account of ability to pay are extremely difficult to implement, and commonly used waiver schemes introduce unfairness and waste of resources; iv) the clear incentive to publishers using such a model to maximize revenue by overstating their costs and accepting and publishing articles without sufficient selectivity or value being added. 

3. We do not support the payment/reimbursement of author fees by funding agencies, because this does nothing to control the level of such fees, and further privileges researchers already helped by funders. 

4. Instead, we strongly support the model of open access journals whose production costs are paid by consortial membership contributions transparently related to publishing costs but not directly linked to specific authors or articles (for example, Open Library of Humanities, Redalyc, SciPost). We call on all research funders to take immediate steps to support such organizations of journals. 

5. The above is consistent with and informed by the 4th Fair Open Access Principle...."


From feeds:

Open Access Tracking Project (OATP) » peter.suber's bookmarks

Tags: oa.fees oa.signatures oa.business_models oa.fair oa.recommendations oa.declarations oa.journals

Date tagged:

01/20/2019, 10:26

Date published:

01/20/2019, 05:25