Ask me anything: moral judgments edition
Shtetl-Optimized 2018-08-02
Reader Lewikee asked when I’d do another “Ask Me Anything.” So fine, let’s do one now (and for the next 24 hours or so, or until I get too fatigued). The rules:
- This time around, only questions that ask me to render a moral judgment on some issue, which could be personal, political, or both (I answer plenty of quantum and complexity questions in the comments sections of other posts…)
- One question per person total; no multipart questions or questions that require me to watch a video or read a linked document
- Anything nasty, sneering, or non-genuine will be left in the moderation queue at my discretion
Let me get things started with the following judgment:
It is morally wrong to lie to parents that you’re taking their children away from them for 20 minutes to give them a bath, but then instead separate the children from their parents indefinitely, imprison the parents, and confine the children in giant holding facilities where they can no longer be contacted, as United States border agents are apparently now doing. And yes, I know that people sometimes make such proclamations not out of genuine moral concern, but simply to virtue-signal for their chosen tribe and attack a rival tribe. However, as someone who’s angered and offended nearly every tribe on his blog, I hope I might be taken at face value if I simply say: this is wrong.
Update (June 18): OK, thanks to everyone who participated! I’ll circle back to the few questions I haven’t yet gotten to, but no new questions please.