Editorial: Symposium “Pre-results review” | Experimental Economics

"we are convinced that pre-results review is an option that solves many problems concerning the replication crisis. This Symposium also shows that it is feasible in principle. For Experimental Economics, we see two reasons to consider it risky to roll it out at the current stage. First, more experience is needed to know how the process scales up. Second, pre-results review is still uncommon in economics, and so Experimental Economics might lose in-principle-accepted papers to top journals."