Another Reason Why Diamond Access Makes Sense: No Economic Barriers To Publishing Rebuttals

peter.suber's bookmarks 2023-12-27

Summary:

"Rebuttal articles are a vital part of the scientific publishing process, since they help weed out mistakes made by other researchers, usually honest errors, but sometimes not. As the Web Ecology editorial notes, writing rebuttal articles is hard enough because of their necessarily confrontational nature. But anyone wanting to publish rebuttals in open access titles that are funded through article processing charges (APCs), generally paid by the researcher’s academic institution, has to contend with an additional problem. In this case, as well as writing cogent explanations why published research is faulty, people who wish to publish a rebuttal must generally pay an APC to do so....

The fact that they can publish rebuttals quickly and without demanding a payment to do so is yet another reason they are the best form of open access available."

Link:

https://www.techdirt.com/2023/12/27/another-reason-why-diamond-access-makes-sense-no-economic-barriers-to-publishing-rebuttals/

From feeds:

Open Access Tracking Project (OATP) » peter.suber's bookmarks
Music and Digital Media » Techdirt.

Tags:

oa.new oa.no-fee oa.benefits oa.journals

Authors:

Mike Masnick

Date tagged:

12/27/2023, 20:35

Date published:

12/27/2023, 08:29