She sent a letter pointing out problems with a published article, the reviewers agreed that her comments were valid, but the journal didn’t publish her letter because “the policy among editors is not to accept comments.”

The journal in question is called The Economic Journal. To add insult to injury, the editor wrote the following when announcing they wouldn’t publish the letter: My [the editor’s] assessment is that this paper is a better fit for a field journal in education. OK, let me get this straight. The original paper, which was […]