Cops Love Body Camera Footage... When It Clears Officers Of Any Wrongdoing

Cops have a "tell." It's so obvious and yet they still pretend it isn't. Whenever something questionable goes down, all anyone has to do is ask for the recordings.

If the recording exonerates cops (or at least makes it a close call in their favor), law enforcement agencies will release the footage, often without anyone asking for it. If there might be rights violations or a questionable killing, cops will delay or deny the release of footage. In some cases, no footage is recorded at all. In others, the footage will go missing.

This "tell" is highlighted in a recent ACLU post, which compares the responsiveness of two law enforcement agencies. The one that can't immediately justify officers' actions chose to withhold, asserting a bunch of stipulations, policies, and public records exceptions to justify its lack of transparency.

The other chose to proactively release footage in hopes of talking the public into supporting its controversial actions by showing everything wasn't nearly as awful as the high-profile warrant target would make it seem.

First, we have the footage that exonerates law enforcement officers. Earlier this month, Florida law enforcement raided the house of a COVID whistleblower -- a former government employee who was kicked to the curb when COVID stats failed to match the state governor's "EVERYTHING IS FINE" pronouncements. The whistleblower claimed cops pointed guns at her children and otherwise acted excessively given the nature of the charges.

And this remains true, despite the proactive body cam footage release. Cops with guns raided a house over allegations that some hacking had occurred. In reality, the situation was much more muddy, involving a state government system that allowed people to share a password and a supposedly threatening message. When computer crime is responded to by officers with guns and the authorization to use deadly force, things are a bit fucked up. Yes, law enforcement is there to enforce laws, but keyboard warriors use keyboards, not guns. Entering a house with guns drawn drastically overestimates the "danger" officers are facing.

After being excoriated in the press and on social media, the law enforcement agency decided to clear the air. But DO NOT CONGRATULATE. This "transparency" had a clear goal -- and that goal wasn't to place the agency on the top of the transparency charts.

[I]n the Florida case, police body camera footage appears to show the state police acting in a more restrained manner than Jones was alleging. As a result, in what CNN properly noted to be a “rare move”, the state police released the body camera footage publicly, and they did it quickly. Transparency prevailed, but only because it favored the police.

This "raid" wasn't much of a raid. That's why Florida state police released the bodycam footage.

The two videos released by the department show that Jones didn't exit her Tallahassee home until about 23 minutes after officers first rang the doorbell, and 15 minutes after they first announced themselves as police.

When it makes cops seem like the good guys they proclaim themselves to be, transparency abounds. When things are more questionable, cops play it close to the vest, acting like legal scholars with years of litigation experience behind them, rather than the people