the editors speak: what makes a good review | orgtheory.net
philipncohen's bookmarks 2018-09-03
Summary:
One of the most important things we do as members of an intellectual community is assist in peer review. As important as it is, reviewing papers is one of the tasks that receives the least amount of attention in graduate school training. ... I asked a number of current and former editors at journals in organizational theory and sociology to comment about what they think makes a good review. This post includes their thoughts.